19,596
edits
m (grammar review, part 2) |
m (grammar review, part 3) |
||
Line 271: | Line 271: | ||
====Ninja-SLDs a.k.a Daodan-droids?==== | ====Ninja-SLDs a.k.a Daodan-droids?==== | ||
[http://oni2.net/irclog.php?chan=oni&showtype=showrange&rangestart=1189348501&rangeend=1189355701&nochange=1#121507 Daodandroids] are an | [http://oni2.net/irclog.php?chan=oni&showtype=showrange&rangestart=1189348501&rangeend=1189355701&nochange=1#121507 Daodandroids] are an invention of geyser's. | ||
[http://oni2.net/irclog.php?chan=oni&showtype=showrange&rangestart=1189961817&rangeend=1189969017&nochange=1#123453 Guido]: Serguei uses this idea as an explanation of Mukade control over the ninjas. | [http://oni2.net/irclog.php?chan=oni&showtype=showrange&rangestart=1189961817&rangeend=1189969017&nochange=1#123453 Guido]: Serguei uses this idea as an explanation of Mukade's control over the ninjas. | ||
Here's [http://oni2.net/irclog.php?chan=oni&showtype=showrange&rangestart=1188140623&rangeend=1188147823&nochange=1#114292 another page]. | Here's [http://oni2.net/irclog.php?chan=oni&showtype=showrange&rangestart=1188140623&rangeend=1188147823&nochange=1#114292 another page]. Ninjas are all left-handed. Geyser rejected this fact as pure "gamemaking stuff". | ||
I began to like | I began to like the idea of Daodan-droids, so I ''forked'' that idea to fit into RS. | ||
And I still think the brain engrams can be a good explanation of SLDs' left-handedness. Anyway ... | And I still think the brain engrams can be a good explanation of SLDs' left-handedness. Anyway ... | ||
Line 283: | Line 283: | ||
: * * * * * | : * * * * * | ||
The more power and exclusive knowledge a group possesses, the more need they have for trustworthy members. | |||
After Hasegawa, Kimura and Pensatore created the Ego Hybrida “Mukade” their combined knowledge demanded a new level of trustworthiness. Based on Kimura’s brain engrams they created a bunch of SLDs. A drawback of this solution was their disguise. To prevent detection the group aims to replace more and more artificial | After Hasegawa, Kimura and Pensatore created the Ego Hybrida “Mukade”, their combined knowledge demanded a new level of trustworthiness. Based on Kimura’s brain engrams, they created a bunch of SLDs. A drawback of this solution was their disguise. To prevent detection, the group aims to replace more and more artificial parts with the Daodan biomass. Barabas showed that this mixing is possible. Mukade also wants to regain a biological body someday, not knowing his donors are still alive... | ||
Idea: what happens if we take Mukade's name literally? | Idea: what happens if we take Mukade's name literally? | ||
Maybe his body is ''currently'' in a stage that allows him add a lot of torsos of his Daodan-droids. | Maybe his body is ''currently'' in a stage that allows him add a lot of torsos of his Daodan-droids. His many arms might then give him the appearance of a centipede. (If we ever get a new game engine, let's create a new boss battle ... lol) | ||
Line 300: | Line 300: | ||
B) Hasegawa takes a nap. | B) Hasegawa takes a nap. | ||
In Pensatore's opinion Mukade | In Pensatore's opinion, Mukade has accumulated too much power. | ||
Inspired by the Daodan, he has his own plan now | Inspired by the Daodan, he has his own plan now: the Omega-Chimera, successor of the SLD, is supposed to form a Biocracy. | ||
He tries to take control over Muro. Sturmänderung is absolutely unnecessary. | He tries to take control over Muro. Sturmänderung is absolutely unnecessary. | ||
Line 308: | Line 308: | ||
Mukade (Ego-Hybrida) sends a man after Pensatore. The scientists are currently working in an underwater lab in Antarctica. | Mukade (Ego-Hybrida) sends a man after Pensatore. The scientists are currently working in an underwater lab in Antarctica. | ||
In an accident Hasegawa drowns. His body can be retrieved but his mind is beyond repair. (When Mai finds him, she collapses.) | In an accident, Hasegawa drowns. His body can be retrieved, but his mind is beyond repair. (When Mai finds him, she collapses.) | ||
Only Pensatore is able to repair Hasegawa's mind with brain | Only Pensatore is able to repair Hasegawa's mind with the brain engrams Mukade is using, but he refuses. Hasegawa is now a "frozen guarantee". | ||
===Some more political/social/ethical aspects=== | ===Some more political/social/ethical aspects=== | ||
====Hasegawa's philosophy: death is worse than questionable ethics==== | ====Hasegawa's philosophy: death is worse than questionable ethics==== | ||
: Hasegawa: "In a democracy you need the majority to change a situation. But in the WCG there's no such thing | : Hasegawa: "In a democracy, you need the majority to change a situation. But in the WCG, there's no such thing as a majority, nor a democracy. We failed to accomplish our hopes through normal means. Now, only a revolution can bring change. If you don't have the guts to pull it off, then I will do it. Or rather... if all of society's intelligence wasn't enough to ensure our survival, then I will empower the human body to protect ourselves." | ||
Pensatore: "Usually revolutions turn out to be quite bloody. Many people will die in the chaos. From a scientist I | Pensatore: "Usually revolutions turn out to be quite bloody. Many people will die in the chaos. From a scientist, I would expect a more ethical suggestion." | ||
: "Ethics for its own sake is not an option. Look at history. On the verge of death men [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uruguayan_Air_Force_Flight_571#Cannibalism ate other men]<!--also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cannibalism#World_War_II-->, even corpses | : "Ethics for its own sake is not an option. Look at history. On the verge of death, men [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uruguayan_Air_Force_Flight_571#Cannibalism ate other men]<!--also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cannibalism#World_War_II-->, even corpses, for one simple reason: to survive. And even devout Christians have come to the conclusion that death to a megalomaniac dictator can be justified. -- Ethics are only as good as the situation allows them to be! Of how much worth are rules and laws which don't let you survive?" | ||
"And you believe we are in such a situation? Certainly, the WCG isn't the | "And you believe we are in such a situation? Certainly, the WCG isn't the optimal solution, but this is a bit too much in my opinion. -- What do you have in mind? Do you want as a geneticist to make a biological intervention that takes away all of the control humans have wrested from mother nature in the last [[wikipedia:Control_of_fire_by_early_humans|125,000 years]]?" | ||
: "What | : "What value is fire to men, when they burn themselves and hardly learn from their mistakes? -- No, I'm not throwing it away, just taking a part and giving it to a new version of ourselves. Those new possibilities will create a society where conflicts of interest and foul compromises can be avoided." | ||
"What are the details of your plan?" | "What are the details of your plan?" | ||
: "All our cells collect information which they use in cases of emergency to transform themselves. That inner safeguard will have the possibility to compensate injuries caused by wrong decisions the human mind made." | : "All our cells collect information which they use in cases of emergency to transform themselves. That inner safeguard will have the possibility to compensate for injuries caused by wrong decisions the human mind made." | ||
"A biocracy ... on cellular level?" | "A biocracy ... on a cellular level?" | ||
: "I call it a Daodan | : "I call it a Daodan Chrysalis." | ||
"I must say | "I must say again, such radical changes will trigger fear, chaos and death!" | ||
: "We live in permanent evolution and that brings always unknown | : "We live in permanent evolution, and that brings always unknown changes. All I will do is to speed things up. I bet you could sell it as a genetic upgrade against diseases, and then there would be fewer problems." | ||
"Do you suggest | "Do you suggest lying to everybody?" | ||
: "Have you ever told your children that Santa brings | : "Have you ever told your children that Santa brings them presents? -- Even if we aren't aware of it, [http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,2051177,00.html we lie daily]." | ||
"That's | "That's totally different. If Muro ripped off your beard, then he might be disappointed to not see Santa. But if someone finds out what your project is really about, then we have again a horrific scenario." | ||
: "We don't need to force people to get | : "We don't need to force people to get a Daodan." | ||
"A parallel society with mutants doesn't make the situation | "A parallel society with mutants doesn't necessarily make the situation better." | ||
: "Would you blame me for the racism of other people?" | : "Would you blame me for the racism of other people?" | ||
"You want to | "You want to bring the Daodan into this world, and you also know how people will react. So yes, you would be responsible." | ||
: "Oh, that | : "Oh, that makes it really easy for you..." | ||
"Listen, I know that Jamie's death was a tragedy for you and all others who knew her. But do you really think she would have wanted | "Listen, I know that Jamie's death was a tragedy for you and all others who knew her. But do you really think she would have wanted innocents to die from your innovation? -- You should find a way to introduce your project to the world in a slow pace." | ||
: "I want to use my anger and desperation to create a change." | : "I want to use my anger and desperation to create a change." | ||
: "I don't want to return to a calm mindset where daily life takes over. This | : "I don't want to return to a calm mindset where daily life takes over. This is what got us into this situation. -- I know the Daodan comes with risks. But life without the necessity of taking risks is an illusion." | ||
At this point Mukade can drop in and suggest | At this point, Mukade can drop in and suggest using the Daodan as a ''carrot'' to infiltrate the Syndicate, then "repair" the ACCs and bring down the WCG little by little. | ||
In that scenario the Daodan wouldn't change the people but the existing political system. | In that scenario, the Daodan wouldn't change the people, but rather the existing political system. | ||
Line 456: | Line 456: | ||
|} | |} | ||
Side note: [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xb5ojdciO1E "When the wild wind blows" by Iron Maiden] (up to time code 10:00) might fit for an AMV-styled video of a custom level featuring Jamie and the Prof. in the city and the wilderness. On | Side note: [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xb5ojdciO1E "When the wild wind blows" by Iron Maiden] (up to time code 10:00) might fit for an AMV-styled video of a custom level featuring Jamie and the Prof. in the city and the wilderness. On second thought, it could be also used for the Sturmänderung event.--> | ||
====What arguments speak against the Daodan?==== | ====What arguments speak against the Daodan?==== | ||
Line 464: | Line 464: | ||
In order to successfully advertise the Daodan critical | In order to successfully advertise the Daodan, those critical objections must be rendered baseless. But can that be done, or is the Daodan really to be feared? | ||
'''1a) Psychological impact on others.''' | '''1a) Psychological impact on others.''' | ||
Line 476: | Line 476: | ||
At the latest when you run into a group of [https://www.google.de/search?q=Abara&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=7kC5U4eEBqOJzAO2voGwBA&ved=0CAgQ_AUoAQ&biw=1600&bih=1040 Abara look-alikes], this will stress your sense of safety. | At the latest when you run into a group of [https://www.google.de/search?q=Abara&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=7kC5U4eEBqOJzAO2voGwBA&ved=0CAgQ_AUoAQ&biw=1600&bih=1040 Abara look-alikes], this will stress your sense of safety. | ||
When you can't distinguish between humans and animals you soon have a fantasy setting similar to some MMO. Cooperation will just depend | When you can't distinguish between humans and animals, you soon have a fantasy setting similar to some MMO. Cooperation will just depend on people's willingness to accept or reject different appearances. | ||
'''1b) Unwanted autoevolution (lack of control).''' | '''1b) Unwanted autoevolution (lack of control).''' | ||
You might get traits that | You might get traits that ensure better survival but are inconvenient in the matter of aesthetics. Or you planned to go somewhere, but now it is physically impossible. | ||
With cybernetics you wouldn't have such problem. You would be free to add or remove any feature. | With cybernetics, you wouldn't have such a problem. You would be free to add or remove any feature. | ||
'''1c) Evolutionary dead ends.''' | '''1c) Evolutionary dead ends.''' | ||
It's said that evolution can go only forward eventually leading | It's said that evolution can go only forward, eventually leading to dead ends where no more adaptation can take place, due to the previous adaptations. | ||
However, the Daodan's | However, the Daodan's analytical nature might circumnavigate this cliff. | ||
'''2a) I am still myself, the original?''' | '''2a) I am still myself, the original?''' | ||
After the Daodan replaced all original cells what happened to the old personality | After the Daodan replaced all the original cells, what happened to the old personality? Was it killed and replaced by a clone's personality? | ||
That's a very | That's a very philosophical question. It would be very easy to spread fear with that one, if not explained in detail. | ||
Line 503: | Line 503: | ||
This is similar to teleportation. | This is similar to teleportation. | ||
A person enters the teleporter. Information becomes copied and matter destroyed. The information | A person enters the teleporter. Information becomes copied, and matter destroyed. The information is transfered. Then the person is rebuilt. If there's anything like a soul, was it killed? How can we be sure this is the same person? | ||
Now let's imagine we teleport everything but the brain from | Now let's imagine we teleport everything but the brain from point A to point B. The mind is still at point A, isn't it? | ||
Next, we teleport one brain cell. The brain will still work as it always did | Next, we teleport one brain cell. The brain will still work as it always did if we somehow manage to [[wikipedia:Quantum_entanglement|entangle]] all cell functions at point B with rest of the brain at point A. | ||
We are looking here at a mind that has physically different residences but it's still only one mind. | We are looking here at a mind that has physically different residences, but it's still only one mind. | ||
If we repeat this for every brain | If we repeat this for every brain cell, there would be always just one mind at any time, and likewise when 50% is at point A and 50% at point B. | ||
After we completed this special teleportation we would have no doubt that the person is truly the person that went into the teleporter chamber. | After we completed this special teleportation, we would have no doubt that the person is truly the person that went into the teleporter chamber. | ||
Line 519: | Line 519: | ||
Now let's look at cell growth/death a bit. | Now let's look at cell growth/death a bit. | ||
There's speculation | There's ongoing speculation on how many cells die every second in the human body. The estimates range from many thousand to a few million. | ||
The important point for us is that the body and hence brain is in constant state of change. | The important point for us is that the body, and hence brain, is in constant state of change. | ||
Cells divide and die | Cells divide and die every day, and we don't ask ourselves, "Are we still the same?" | ||
Apparently we are okay with that. Cells die, some get replaced. | Apparently we are okay with that. Cells die, and some get replaced. | ||
So | So for the Daodan we can imagine that our brain cells get replaced one by one, so that normal and upgraded cells are always linked. | ||
The mind remains original at any time. We are just changing to | The mind remains original at any time. We are just changing to different hardware. | ||
Line 538: | Line 538: | ||
Probably a change in personality would be caused indirectly. | Probably a change in personality would be caused indirectly. | ||
An aggressive person might outlive his strategy and become more aggressive because negative consequences would have a smaller impact on him. | An aggressive person might outlive his strategy and become more aggressive, because negative consequences would have a smaller impact on him. | ||
'''3) [[#Contamination_of_the_ecosystem|Horizontal gene transfer.]]''' | '''3) [[#Contamination_of_the_ecosystem|Horizontal gene transfer.]]''' | ||
Why is this something bad? The Daodan gives humans an | Why is this something bad? The Daodan gives humans an incredibly huge advantage against all other lifeforms. | ||
If the Daodan mechanisms are shared | If the Daodan's mechanisms are shared by the rest of nature, hyperevolution will take place everywhere, making it harder to adapt again. | ||
While viruses might learn some new tricks they should remain less potent than a multi-cellular Daodan. | While viruses might learn some new tricks, they should remain less potent than a multi-cellular Daodan. | ||
So the actual thread would be bacterial colonies. | So the actual thread would be bacterial colonies. | ||
Line 555: | Line 555: | ||
What arguments could someone use in public to advertise the Daodan?<br> | What arguments could someone use in public to advertise the Daodan?<br> | ||
'''1) regenerate lost limbs, faster wound healing, avoid cancer'''<br> | '''1) regenerate lost limbs, faster wound healing, avoid cancer'''<br> | ||
'''2) compensate slow-paced invention cycles'''<br> | '''2) compensate for slow-paced invention cycles'''<br> | ||
'''3) compensate lack of natural selection'''<br> | '''3) compensate for a lack of natural selection'''<br> | ||
'''4) compensate | '''4) compensate for man's habit of putting himself in dangerous situations''' | ||
Line 563: | Line 563: | ||
'''2) Some events just happen too fast for | '''2) Some events just happen too fast for bureaucracy and standard medical procedures.''' | ||
Without a drastic improvement there could be never a cure for a new deadly pathogen | Without a drastic improvement, there could be never a cure for a new deadly pathogen that can kill within hours. | ||
This is the point that Hasegawa would had in mind when he tried to find a cure for Jamie's disease. | This is the point that Hasegawa would have had in mind when he tried to find a cure for Jamie's disease. | ||
'''3) Many humans | '''3) Many humans are no longer subject to natural selection, which is good in the short-term but bad in the long-term.''' | ||
In real life the lack of genetic fitness is somewhat compensated by human's mental fitness which is expressed in applied science, namely: medicine. | In real life, the lack of genetic fitness is somewhat compensated by human's mental fitness, which is expressed in applied science, namely: medicine. | ||
The health care systems (especially in the western world) enable even heavily diseased people to survive and raise children. | The health care systems (especially in the western world) enable even heavily diseased people to survive and raise children. | ||
So, when people stay alive no matter their | So, when people stay alive no matter their genetic fitness level, natural selection can't take place, and diseases continue to remain deadly. | ||
Let's say | Let's say that HIV isn't treated at all: wouldn't the whole human race die out? | ||
No. For instance every 10th European is naturally immune against HIV. So if we had a real plague only the immune people would survive and in the future HIV would be a far smaller problem. | No. For instance, every 10th European is naturally immune against HIV. So if we had a real plague, only the immune people would survive, and in the future HIV would be a far smaller problem. | ||
A historical example of this kind of immunization is the Spanish Flu from 1918, which was the most catastrophic disease in human history so far. The price, immunity, came at the cost of a gigantic mountain of corpses, more than 50 million dead people if you trust the recent estimates. | |||
With human's current knowledge | With human's current knowledge, it's possible the first outbreak couldn't have been prevented, but at least it wouldn't kill good portions of the world population. | ||
With HIV we are facing a dilemma: | With HIV, we are facing a dilemma: either we keep everybody alive, at the cost of a reduced lifespan, a weakened immune systems, social restrictions, discrimination, etc. or we let natural selection happen for the population's sake, so gaining immunity. Both options are unacceptable for us humans as emotional beings. We seek better solutions, but for some reasons we have failed so far. | ||
'''4) Humans often act | '''4) Humans often act unwisely.''' | ||
At this point we could simply link to some "fail compilations" on YouTube. (Or if you prefer parodies, | At this point we could simply link to some "fail compilations" on YouTube. (Or if you prefer parodies, check out this German classic, "[[wikipedia:Forklift_Driver_Klaus_%E2%80%93_The_First_Day_on_the_Job|Forklift Driver Klaus]]".) | ||
But there's also | But there's also the more serious category of ''failing big, and systematically'' e.g. when a society does it as a whole. | ||
For instance, in many states antibiotics are overused. It's against one's better judgment but our greed for money makes it easy to ignore dangers that occur in a delayed | For instance, in many states, antibiotics are overused. It's against one's better judgment, but our greed for money makes it easy to ignore dangers that occur in a delayed manner. | ||
We use antibiotics too often to keep ourselves and the livestock healthy. That puts bacteria under [[wikipedia:Evolutionary pressure|evolutionary pressure]]. There are concerns that more ''[[wikipedia:Super_bug_(bacteria)|super bugs]]'' emerge. These | We use antibiotics too often, to keep ourselves and the livestock healthy. That puts bacteria under [[wikipedia:Evolutionary pressure|evolutionary pressure]]. There are concerns that more ''[[wikipedia:Super_bug_(bacteria)|super bugs]]'' will emerge. These multi-drug-resistant bacteria can't be easily killed. The media-popular MRSA strain residing in hospitals is one such danger. | ||
Scientists try to come up with methods to reuse old | Scientists try to come up with methods to reuse old antibiotics, or find new ones. However, it can be assumed that the bacteria will also adapt to the new inventions. It's a never-ending arms race. | ||
An alternative to antibiotics are bacteriophages, or, for short, phages. Russia and Georgia officially use these bacteria-eating viruses in some [[wikipedia:Phage_therapy|therapies]]. Usually viruses adapt even faster than bacteria, but so-called [http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v450/n7172/full/nature06350.html mutators] can win a biological arms race against phages. | |||
<!--https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/139715/OniGalore/RS_T_Sources/mutators.zip--> | <!--https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/139715/OniGalore/RS_T_Sources/mutators.zip--> | ||
If we imagine that all antibiotics will become useless, we would have no | If we imagine that all antibiotics will become useless, we would have no choice but to make massive use of phages, which again causes further adaptations inside the super bugs. | ||