8,452
edits
Paradox-01 (talk | contribs) mNo edit summary |
Paradox-01 (talk | contribs) mNo edit summary |
||
Line 382: | Line 382: | ||
===Are SLDs alive?=== | ===Are SLDs alive?=== | ||
* "The SLD project is an attempt to recreate human physiology with artificial materials." | * "The SLD project is an attempt to recreate human physiology with artificial materials." | ||
* The TCTF | * SLD are classified as androids. | ||
: The TCTF and the Syndicate's language has more weight on the technical side... | |||
:: [[Quotes/Diary#CHAPTER_07_._A_FRIEND_IN_NEED|Konoko]]: "I don't know if they '''programmed''' fear into her but if they didn't she's probably figured it out on her own by now." | |||
:: 08_28_02 Muro: "Curious. Why bother '''programming''' you to feel pain so intensely?" | |||
:: 09_31_08 Shinatama: "I am an SLD, an android '''programmed''' with your brain engrams" | |||
: ... while The SLD scientists seem also to be more open for psychological aspects. | |||
::"SLDs are '''[[Quotes/Consoles/level_3b|individuals]]''' in many respects." | |||
:: "This core '''personality''' is then given a chance to develop a unique neurolattice while experiencing accelerated streaming sensory feeds." | |||
:: "Most SLDs have to spend at least three months in the senseloop, which we have come to think of as their '''psychological''' womb." | |||
* [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergence Emergence] is not limited to one type of molecules, components, etc. | * [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergence Emergence] is not limited to one type of molecules, components, etc. | ||
Maybe the | If they really '''recreated''' human physiology how can they rule out a new ''emerged'' mind? Why would it be a bare ''simulated'' one? Also, the TCTF was really surprised that Shinatama developed an [[Quotes/Consoles/level_18b|own will]]. | ||
: "[...] an unprecedented degree of free will in the android [...]" | |||
Maybe the TCTF argued that a SLD use just "programs" (because the hardware is not biological but artificial) and that programs aren't enough to create a mind. That's a pretty similar thinking to John Searle's [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room Chinese Room]. I wonder if a collection of interacting programs can show emergence. | |||
Line 395: | Line 405: | ||
: [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turing_test#Real_intelligence_vs_simulated_intelligence Turing said:] "I do not wish to give the impression that I think there is no mystery about consciousness. There is, for instance, something of a paradox connected with any attempt to localise it." | : [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turing_test#Real_intelligence_vs_simulated_intelligence Turing said:] "I do not wish to give the impression that I think there is no mystery about consciousness. There is, for instance, something of a paradox connected with any attempt to localise it." | ||
So, simulating life although we don't understand its creation fits into this logic. Humans | So, simulating life although we don't understand its creation fits into this logic. <u>Humans often often physical phenomena even before they fully understood them.</u> For instance, the atomic force for power plants or phase changing materials in in data discs. [http://www.scienceknowledge.org/2011/01/28/the-phase-change-materials-dvd-decrypted-by-the-super-computer/ (Eng)] [http://www.g-o.de/wissen-aktuell-13372-2011-05-04.html (Ger)]<!--alternativ: http://kefk.org/forschung/physik/phase.change.materials.datenspeicher.mit.langzeit.gedaechtnis--> <u>Making things work is sometimes enough.</u> | ||
According to wikipedia the idea of artificial intelligence was born [[wikipedia:History_of_artificial_intelligence#The_birth_of_artificial_intelligence_1943.E2.88.921956|in 1943]] and since then many scientists have tried to create an AI. There are some different attempts to program an AI. So far no attempt succeeded. | According to wikipedia the idea of artificial intelligence was born [[wikipedia:History_of_artificial_intelligence#The_birth_of_artificial_intelligence_1943.E2.88.921956|in 1943]] and since then many scientists have tried to create an AI. There are some different attempts to program an AI. So far no attempt succeeded. | ||
Also mind-uploading is considered as an approach for an AI. In Oni's timeline mind-uploading could already exist if you have an [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strong_AI#Processing_requirements_for_low-level_brain_emulation optimistic view] onto things. (However, the existence of "deadly brains" let assume that AIs are still in development otherwise DBs would be obsolete.) With the obtained data, the mind doesn't need to become ''reinvented'' but analyzed. After the phase of analysis a true artificial intelligence could be designed. | Also mind-uploading is considered as an approach for an AI. In Oni's timeline mind-uploading could already exist if you have an [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strong_AI#Processing_requirements_for_low-level_brain_emulation optimistic view] onto things. (However, the existence of "deadly brains" let assume that AIs are still in development otherwise DBs would be obsolete.) | ||
: "One thing we [[Quotes/Consoles/level_3b|still cannot do]] is create an artificial system that adequately simulates the processes of the human mind." | |||
With the obtained data, the mind doesn't need to become ''reinvented'' but analyzed. After the phase of analysis a true artificial intelligence could be designed. | |||
The third part of the abbreviation has a bit less obvious meaning. "Doll" basically refers to the environment of the simulated life but there are other terms they could have used. Is it possible that the name was influenced by "ghost in the shell"? In this case it's not likely because the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghost_in_the_Shell_2:_Innocence second GITS movie] with dolls as topic was published (2004) after Oni release (2001). | The third part of the abbreviation has a bit less obvious meaning. "Doll" basically refers to the environment of the simulated life but there are other terms they could have used. Is it possible that the name was influenced by "ghost in the shell"? In this case it's not likely because the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghost_in_the_Shell_2:_Innocence second GITS movie] with dolls as topic was published (2004) after Oni release (2001). |
edits