8,013
edits
Talk:Restless Souls/Technology: Difference between revisions
m
no edit summary
Paradox-01 (talk | contribs) mNo edit summary |
Paradox-01 (talk | contribs) mNo edit summary |
||
| Line 529: | Line 529: | ||
Reading material: | Reading material: | ||
* General criticism: LLMs are "stochastic parrots", Emily Bender, [https://www.zeit.de/digital/2023-04/emily-bender-ki-gefahr-ethik zeit.de] | * General criticism: LLMs are "stochastic parrots", Emily Bender, [https://www.zeit.de/digital/2023-04/emily-bender-ki-gefahr-ethik zeit.de] | ||
* Potential loophole: "[LLM] shows how far the approach of stringing together words and word sequences on the basis of statistical probabilities can go. However, there is no evidence that the | * Potential loophole: "[LLM] shows how far the approach of stringing together words and word sequences on the basis of statistical probabilities can go. '''However, there is no evidence that the semantics can be fully deduced via syntactic relations. Then again, the opposite cannot be proven either.'''", [https://www.heise.de/hintergrund/Grenzen-der-Sprach-KI-ChatGPT-zwischen-Effizienz-und-Wunschdenken-7583232.html heise.de] | ||
In philosophical view a GPT is quite similar to a mind-uploaded intelligence whereas language serves as a transport container: semantics via syntax. The training of a LLM is therefore not "learning" but " | In philosophical view a GPT is quite similar to a mind-uploaded intelligence whereas language serves as a transport container: semantics via syntax. The training of a LLM is therefore not "learning" but "rewriting" algorithms from biological to synthetic hardware. And it is good that we cannot do direct mind-uploads of individual minds: | ||
* Beside technical not being possible - there is no way to let one person formulate all his knowledge into text - it avoids person specific bias and ethical questions. | * Beside technical not being possible - there is no way to let one person formulate all his knowledge into text - it avoids person specific bias and ethical questions. | ||
* Active emotions are not transferred into the model. No motivations or biological-based intrinsic dynamics get transported. | * Active emotions are not transferred into the model. No motivations or biological-based intrinsic dynamics get transported. | ||